Nightmare Critters Plush

Nightmare Critters Poppy Playtime Plush

Dive into the eerie world of Poppy Playtime Chapter 4: Safe Haven with the full collection of Nightmare Critters Plush, a twisted line of animal-inspired toys created by Playtime Co. Each character features exaggerated teethy smiles, oversized mouths, and a wildly distinct personality. As the presumed antithesis of the Smiling Critters, these plushies are anything but comforting — and that’s what makes them special.

From Baba Chops, the introverted black sheep, to Rabie Baby, who lives for gossip, and Simon Smoke, the arrogant showoff, every critter brings their own brand of chaos. Whether playing major or minor roles in the chapter’s events, each toy captures the haunting charm and playful wickedness of Playtime Co.’s darkest experiments. With appearances ranging from fleeting cameos to full antagonistic encounters, this set is a must-have for fans who want the complete nightmare.

Nightmare Critters Official Plush

Each plush in this Nightmare Critters 12-inch (30 cm) collection is made from soft, high-quality materials and faithfully replicates the designs from the game. Whether it’s Icky Licky’s competitive smirk, Poe’s brooding expression, or Maggie Mako’s hunger-fueled grin, the details are all here. Collect them all and bring the full chaotic cast home, each with their quirks and creep factor intact.